Back
Miecznikowski_2022_Else_jop
Journal article

Italian non vedo/non si vede + indirect wh-interrogative clause (‘I don't see why/what/how...’) as a marker of disagreement

  • Miecznikowski, Johanna ORCID Istituto di studi italiani (ISI), Facoltà di comunicazione, cultura e società, Università della Svizzera italiana, Svizzera
  • 2022
Published in:
  • Journal of pragmatics. - 2022, vol. 197, no. August, p. 11-26
Disagreeing actions
Evidential strategies
Argumentation
Discourse routines
Perception verbs
Wh-interrogative clauses
Italian
English The paper studies the functions of negated indicative present forms of the verb vedere ‘to see’ that refer to the speaker and are followed by an indirect wh-interrogative subordinate clause. The investigation of an Italian written corpus of newspaper articles, reviews and forum posts shows that this construction set forms a discourse routine with a recurrent pragmatic function. It expresses a disagreeing action of rebuttal that includes the reformulation and critical assessment of an interlocutor’s preceding utterance and projects arguments sustaining the speaker’s standpoint. The routine is highly specialized: its functions are limited to those mentioned, whereas it does not express bare denial, counterarguments, or agreeing actions. The corpus analysis also shows that this specialization is a characteristic of the combination of the examined negated verb forms with indirect wh-interrogative clauses, whereas combinations with other complement types either do not occur at all in the corpus (indirect polar questions and complement clauses introduced by che) or have a broader range of diverse discourse functions (nominal complements with propositional meaning). The routine’s lexical and grammatical components (inferential lexical meaning, deixis, negation and its scope, the presupposing properties of indirect wh-interrogatives, mood) all contribute to realize its discourse function.
Collections
Language
  • English
Classification
Language, linguistics
License
CC BY
Open access status
hybrid
Identifiers
Persistent URL
https://n2t.net/ark:/12658/srd1322476
Statistics
Document views: 26 File downloads:
  • Miecznikowski_2022_Else_jop.pdf: 96